Vatz on Oriole Signings

Great job on Atkins, not so much on Gonzalez

Andy MacPhail certainly has been busy, with the Baltimore Sun reporting the O’s adding Garrett Atkins and Mike Gonzalez, both players in their prime age and some of the better players of the free agent market.  One move I am very happy about, the signing of Atkins, the other not so much, that being Gonzalez.

Garrett Atkins is a third baseman that was in the Rockies system for years.  Last year he had a very poor season, hitting just .226 with nine home runs in 126 games.  The previous three years he had at least 20 dingers and at least a .286 average.  But this is a good move.  The deal is for one-year, which means he is a stopgap at third, giving Josh Bell another year of seasoning before coming to the majors.  Plus Atkins is only 30, and of his five full years of major league play only one, last year, was a bad one.  Sure he played in hitter-friendly Coors Field, but Camden is just as good, and the Orioles might have found a sleeper in free agency.  If nothing else, he is relatively injury-free the last five years and he can also play first base, another Orioles need.

Mike Gonzalez, 31, is a lefty reliever that was the Braves setup man last year that had experience as a closer in Pittsburgh.  Last season he appeared in 80 games in 74.1 innings with a 2.42 ERA and a 90-33 K-BB ratio.  He is a very good lefty relievers that will compete for the Orioles closer position and will at least solidify a bullpen spot.  But I have a few problems with the deal.  By signing him, the Orioles lose their second-round pick in the upcoming draft because Gonzalez was a type-A free agent.  The MLB Draft is a crap shoot but it is a high price to pay for a short reliever in the bullpen, especially with a farm system that needs work at the lower levels.  Plus, he will make at least six million a year for the next two years; again a high price for the Orioles.  If Gonzalez does not become the Orioles closer, then this deal would not be worth it, and right now that role looks like it is a three-way race between Gonzalez, Jim Johnson, and Koji Uehara.

If nothing else, it seems as if Andy MacPhail is spending money the smart way, and getting the right personnel and not rushing up Norfolk prospects.  The 2010 season will still be rough, especially with the NY-Boston arms race heating up, but the team is getting better the right way.

Blog from Dave Vatz 09 Terrapin Grad

There Are 3 Responses to this Post
  1. Ryan

    The flier on Atkins makes sense. Good move.

    I have to disagree with you on Gonzales though.
    Every season he has been healthy, he has been fantastic.
    He is the closer. You don’t pay 12-16 Million for a set-up man. In the AL East, a lefty closer is a huge advantage.
    Its just for 2 years, to start, but, he will solidify an otherwise very young bullpen. With young pitching, you have GOT to win the games your supposed to win.
    As far as a 2nd rounder, its all a crap shoot, but, don’t forget, until the contract is up, WHO KNOWS whats going to happen.

    One, they can trade him at some point and get prospects. Two, if he leaves here as a Type A or B free agent, then the O’s will get the pick back from whatever team signs him.

    I don’t think you should worry about the pick.
    As far as the money goes, the O’s have so much surplus it isn’t even funny. Remember the days of $97 Million payroll and being the highest in MLB? This isn’t gonna strap them for cash or anything. The payroll is at $47, thats nothing. We WANT them to spend money. We WANT the O’s name out there, so maybe other Free Agents will look at Baltimore again. Just think of how many more games we will win with MG there instead of Ray. lol.

    Reply ·   11/12/2019

  2. freddy from boca

    Money should and is not a factor for the Orioles at this time. Also I think the team would prefer that Johnson be their 8th inning set up guy. and hopefully Gonzales becomes an effective closer so I won’t have to hear BRUCE POSNER’S CONSTANT KVETCHING about the Orioles trade of George Sherrill.

    Reply ·   11/12/2019


    I like both moves but I don’t understand how you can praise the Atkins deal. We paid slightly more then he is actually worth(even as a flier). He has gotten worse every year since his big year. A change of scenery can be a good thing but leaving Coors for the AL East pitchers won’t be an easy task for him.

    Reply ·   11/12/2019

Write a Comment!


YoungTerps Tweets

Terp Talk Tweets

Bruce Posner Tweets


Viener Consulting

Saiontz and Kirk

Dr Jeffrey Gaber and Associates
Never Miss a Terp Beat!

Enter your email address: